Interdisciplinary Anthropology and Data Science Master’s Thesis: A Quick and Dirty Project Summary

This is a quick and dirty summary of my master’s practicum research project with Indicia Consulting over the summer of 2018. For anyone interested in more detail, here is a more detailed report, and here is the final report with Indicia. 

Background

My practicum was the sixth stage of a several year-long research project. The California Energy Commission commissioned this larger project to understand the potential relationship between individual energy consumption and technology usage. In stages one through five, we isolated certain clusters of behavior and attitudes around new technology adoption – which Indicia called cybersensitivity – and demonstrated that cybersensitivity tended to associate with a willingness to adopt energy-saving technology like smart meters.

This led to a key question: How can one identify cybersensivity among a broader population such as a community, county, or state? Answering this question was the main goal of my practicum project.

In the past stages of the research project, the team used ethnographic research to establish criteria for whether someone was a cybersensitive based on several hours of interviews and observations about their technology usage. These interviews and observations certainly helped the research team analyze behavioral and attitudinal patterns, determine what patterns were significant, and develop those into the concept of cybersensitivity, but they are too time- and resource-intensive to perform with an entire population. One generally does not have the ability to interview everyone in a community, county, or state. I sought to address this directly in my project.

TaskTimelineTask NameResearch TechniqueDescription
Task 1June 2015-Sept 2018General Project TasksAdministrative (N/A)Developed project scope and timeline, adjusting as the project unfolds
Task 2July 2015 – July 2016Documenting and analyzing emerging attitudes, emotions, experiences, habits, and practices around technology adoptionSurveyConducted survey research to observe patterns of attitudes and behaviors among cybersensitives/awares.
Task 3Sept 2016 – Dec 2016Identifying the attributes and characteristics and psychological drivers of cybersensitivesInterviews and Participant-ObservationConducted in-depth interviews and observations coding for psych factor, energy consumption attitudes and behaviors, and technological device purchasing/usage.
Task 4*Sept 2016 – July 2017Assessing cybersensitives’ valence with technologyStatistical AnalysisTested for statistically significant differences in demographics, behaviors, and beliefs/attitudes between cyber status groups
Task 5Aug 2017 – Dec 2018  Developing critical insights for supporting residential engagement in energy efficient behaviorsStatistical AnalysisAnalyzed utility data patterns of study participants, comparing it with the general population.
Task 6March 2018 – Aug 2018Recommending an alternative energy efficiency potential modelDecision Tree ModelingConstructed decision tree models to classify an individual’s cyber status

Project Goal

The overall goal for the project was to produce a scalable method to assess whether someone exhibits cybersensitivity based on data measurable across an entire population. In doing this, the project also helped address the following research needs:

  1. Created a method to further to scale across a larger population, assessing whether cybersensitives were more willing to adopt energy saving technologies across a community, county, or state
  2. Provided the infrastructure to determine how much promoting energy-saving campaigns targeting cybersensitives specifically would reduce energy consumption in California
  3. Helped the California Energy Commission determine the best means to reach cybersensitives for specific energy-saving campaigns

The Project

I used machine learning modeling to create a decision-making flow to isolate cybersensitives in a population. Random forests and decision trees produced the best models for Indicia’s needs: random forests in accuracy and robustness and decision trees in human decipherability. Through them, I created a programmable yet human-comprehensible framework to determine whether an individual is cybersensitive based on behaviors and other characteristics that an organization could be easily assess within a whole population. Thus, any energy organization could easily understand, replicate, and further develop the model since it was both easy for humans to read and encodable computationally. This way organizations could both use and refine it for their purposes.

Conclusion

This is a quick overview of my master’s practicum project. For more details on what modeling I did, how I did it, what results it produced, and how it fit within the wider needs of the multi-year research project, please see my full report.

I really appreciated the opportunity it posed to get my hands dirty integrating ethnography and data science to help address a real-world problem. This summary only scratches the surface of what Indicia did with the Californian Energy Commission to encourage sustainable energy usage societally. Hopefully, though, it will inspire you to integrate ethnography and data science to address whatever complex questions you face. It certainly did for me.

Thank you to Susan Mazur-Stommen and Haley Gilbert for your help in organizing and completing the project. I would like to thank my professorial committee at the University of Memphis – Dr. Keri Brondo, Dr. Ted Maclin, Dr. Deepak Venugopal, and Dr. Katherine Hicks – for their academic support as well.

Anthropology by Data Science: The EPIC Project with Indicia Consulting as an Exploratory Case Study

This is my practicum report with Indicia Consulting. In lieu of a master’s thesis, the University of Memphis Department of Anthropology required that we master’s students conduct a practicum project. For this, we had to partner with an organization and complete a 300+ hour anthropological research project based on the organization’s needs and our skills and interests. My practicum project was Indicia’s EPIC Project with the California Energy Commission (see this link and this link for more details on the EPIC Project). In this report, I outline potential ways to integrate ethnographic/anthropological and data science research in professional settings.

In November 2019, the American Anthropological Association’s Committee for the Anthropology of Science, Technology, and Computing (CASTAC) awarded me the David Hakken Graduate Student Prize for innovative science and technology scholarship.

Full Report:

Loader Loading…
EAD Logo Taking too long?

Reload Reload document
| Open Open in new tab

Download [1.56 MB]

The Anthropology Department also required that you publicly present your practicum research to the University of Memphis campus. This PowerPoint summarizes my practicum project. If you are not keen to read the 99 page full report, this is a much shorter alternative:

If you are interested in learning more about the project, please check out the following:

  1. Indicia Consulting’s Final Research Report with the California Energy Commission
  2. My Presentation at the 2019 Memphis Data Conference for Data Scientists Specifically

Memphis Data Conference: Anthropology by Data Science: The EPIC Project with Indicia Consulting as an Exploratory Case Study

Below is a talk I gave at the 2019 Memphis Data conference, organized by the University of Memphis to discuss data science research in the Memphian community. In this presentation, I summarize a project I did with Indicia Consulting that integrated data science and ethnography.

Check out these articles for a more detailed description of the projects: a short project summary, my master’s thesis about the project, and Indicia’s full report.